HSK 7–9 grammar · pattern
哪有X这么Y的/有X这样Y的吗
哪有X这么Y的 — whoever heard of X being so Y
Pattern
+ + + +
+ + + +
( ) can be left out · other words may come before, between and after
How it works
A rhetorical protest that something breaks all reasonable norms: "whoever heard of…?". No answer is expected — the speaker is objecting. The final 的 is required, and the 有…吗 version is equally common.
Examples
哪有这么做生意的？
Nǎ yǒu zhème zuò shēngyi de?
Whoever heard of doing business like that?
有你这样当哥哥的吗？
Yǒu nǐ zhèyàng dāng gēge de ma?
What kind of older brother behaves like this?
Related
See it in a story
In the app, 哪有X这么Y的/有X这样Y的吗 is underlined wherever it appears in the stories you read, and practised with sentences from them. Free.